A Real Estate Discussion Blog


Guest post by Stan Humphries: How Soft is the Housing Market?

This post was written by Zillow's Chief Economist, Dr Stan Humphries. It was originally written on Zillow Blog.

We got some encouraging news last week about March existing-home sales increasing almost 7% from their levels in February. Unfortunately, a deeper look at the numbers from the National Association of Realtors reveals that inventory of for-sale homes also increased. Despite the higher number of sales, more homes were added to the market in March than were sold. Figure 1 below shows the overall inventory of homes on the market.

Figure 1 below shows the overall inventory of homes on the market.

Figure 2 shows the balance between homes sold each month, and the net of homes added or withdrawn each month (so, if more homes are added to the market than are withdrawn or sold, the number will be positive - see below for more detailed methodology).

While the fact that March sales numbers are increasing is undoubtedly a positive sign, the time series shown in Figure 2 does make one at least ponder whether the market is currently capable of clearing itself of inventory without paying people to buy homes (i.e., the homebuyer tax credit currently in place).  Most of our traction in working down inventory levels came in the late summer/fall of last year when home sales were spurred by the threat that the tax credits were going to expire.  Before and after that period, the addition of new inventory for sale usually outpaced sales, keeping inventory levels flat or rising.

This dynamic is being driven by the significant amount of "pent-up supply" in the market right now, that is, the pool of homeowners who have wanted to sell their homes in the past three years but, because of market conditions, either didn't try or were unsuccessful.  Our last estimates of the size of this group of homeowners were that 8% of homeowners indicated that they were very likely to try to sell their homes in the next twelve months if they saw signs of improvement in their local markets.  These sidelined sellers closely watch the market for signs of a possible turnaround and rush in if there's a hint of good news.

We'll very likely see another mini-frenzy in home sales as we approach June (when the current tax credits are set to expire), although I doubt the boost will be as large as we saw last fall.  The ability of this purchased demand to push inventory levels down will be challenged by the flow of new listings into the inventory pool, something that happens each spring and summer.

It will be bad if we don't make much headway in pushing down inventory levels through June, because we will undoubtedly see a reduction in home sales on a monthly basis in July and August (the "payback" of the tax credit seen from shifting demand that would have occurred in those months forward into the pre-July period).  This mid-summer drop-off will likely increase inventory levels so, if we haven't been successful in pushing them down before then, we'll likely end up with more inventory on the market than we have now, even after what is likely to be a robust homebuyer season in the spring and summer.

A few more details about how we arrived at the numbers in Figure 2: The formula used to arrive at the net number of homes added or withdrawn was:

March inventory - February inventory + Number of homes sold in March

If no new homes were added or withdrawn from the inventory in a given month, then the difference between the inventory levels in March and February would exactly equal the number of home sales in the current month and this net number would equal zero.

Additionally, all statistics used in this analysis were from the National Association of Realtors March existing-home sales report.


Like what you're reading?  Then subscribe to my blog to receive updates.  

Follow Me on Twitter   My Outside Blog   Watch my Crazy Movies on YouTube 





   Thanks for reading!  Subscribe here to be alerted of blog updates. rss sara bonert blog zillow  

Want to learn how to use Zillow better?  Check out:



I'm on Twitter too! Follow me at @sbonert


Comment balloon 4 commentsSara Bonert • April 27 2010 08:51PM


What about the relesae of the "shadow inventory" of homes banks are holding?  That will definitely affect the supply side of the equation.

Posted by Loan Survivor Real Estate Financing Expert (Purchases, First Time Buyers, Pre-Approvals, Refinance) over 9 years ago

Sara, In our supply side economy values will change as the inventory competes for fewer buyers in the market. Once the $8,000 tax credit expires we'll have to see...if a significant slow down occurs.

Posted by Steve Loynd, 800-926-5653, White Mountains NH ( Alpine Lakes Real Estate Inc., ) over 9 years ago

I have been noticing locally that the inventory remains about the same or a little higher even as the volume of closings increase. Thanks. Time to look at some more Zillow data!

Posted by Gary L. Waters Broker Associate, Bucci Realty, Fifteen Years Experience in Brevard County (Bucci Realty, Inc.) over 9 years ago


Underwater homeowners, plenty of them in Vegas and other hard-hit areas, won't be able to sell and many of them will end up as bank REOs and keep the supply side high for a while longer.

Posted by Esko Kiuru over 9 years ago